35% of consumers cite prior experience as their main brand driver, not values or messaging.
Most brands approach conscious consumers like they're walking values calculators, carefully weighing ethical considerations with every purchase. Our data tells a completely different story—one revealed most clearly when we examined how consumers actually choose between brands like IKEA, Whirlpool, GE, and emerging conscious players like Ecobee and Anderson Windows & Doors.
→ Click here to get a free assessment to identify which proof points you're missing and create a custom action plan.
The Five-Segment Reality
Our research reveals that the conscious consumer market breaks into five distinct segments with dramatically different behaviors:
14% Core Conscious Consumers who consistently act on their values
22% Likely Conscious Consumers actively moving toward conscious choices
37% Aspirational Conscious Consumers who want to be conscious but struggle with action
18% Unlikely Conscious Consumers with limited interest in values-based purchasing
9% Not Conscious Consumers who don't factor values into decisions
The largest segment (37%) is Aspirational: they want to make conscious choices but face real barriers. This group represents the biggest growth opportunity for conscious brands, yet most marketing completely misses what they actually need.
Experience Beats Values Across All Segments
When we asked consumers to explain their brand choices, experience dominated across every segment. But here's what's fascinating: 46% of Core Conscious Consumers cite experience as their primary driver—the highest of any group.
The people most committed to conscious consumption are also most focused on whether brands deliver excellent experiences. This completely flips the assumption that values-driven consumers will tolerate inferior performance for ethical benefits.
Breaking down by segment:
Core Conscious: 46% experience-driven
Likely Conscious: 36% experience-driven
Aspirational: 34% experience-driven
Unlikely: 30% experience-driven
Not Conscious: 26% experience-driven
Why Legacy Brands Still Win Conscious Consumers
When we examined which brands conscious consumers actually choose, the results reveal why experience trumps values messaging. Legacy brands dominate—not despite their lack of sustainability-first positioning, but because they've spent decades banking trust through consistent performance.
Brand experience as primary selection driver:
Wayfair: 56% of Conscious Consumers cite experience
Whirlpool: 54% of Conscious Consumers cite experience
GE: 41% of Conscious Consumers cite experience
IKEA: 40% of Conscious Consumers cite experience
These brands win because consumers know exactly what they're getting. Decades of consistent delivery create unconscious trust that values messaging alone can't replicate. When a conscious consumer chooses Whirlpool, they're not ignoring their values—they're prioritizing the certainty that the appliance will perform reliably for years.
The pattern holds across consumer segments. Among Aspirational Conscious Consumers—the largest and fastest-growing segment—GE leads with 49% citing experience, Whirlpool follows at 46%, and Wayfair at 35%. Even among Unlikely Conscious Consumers, Whirlpool (40%), GE (40%), and Wayfair (39%) dominate on experience.
But here's where it gets interesting for conscious brands: IKEA proves that legacy scale and values leadership aren't mutually exclusive. While 40% of Conscious Consumers cite IKEA for experience, 24% of all U.S. residents say IKEA best aligns with their values—the highest of any brand in our study. When asked specifically about social impact, 42% of Aspirational Conscious Consumers selected IKEA, more than double any other brand.
IKEA demonstrates what happens when a brand with established experience credibility also leads on values. It's not choosing between experience and values—it's delivering both.
The Performance Problem No One Talks About
Here's the stat that should worry every conscious brand: 58% of health/wellness-focused consumers cite inferior taste/performance as the main barrier to buying conscious products.
Our research revealed specific performance concerns across different conscious consumer priorities:
Health/Wellness Benefits (the largest priority group):
58% cite inferior taste/performance as barrier
51% cite higher costs
50% cite lack of information
Environmental Impact:
34% cite greenwashing/misinformation as barrier
28% cite competing priorities
24% cite higher costs
Social Impact:
21% cite competing priorities
20% cite time/effort required
17% cite distrust in brands/institutions
The message is unmistakable: conscious consumers want to buy values-aligned products, but they won't sacrifice performance to do it. This is why Wayfair can capture 56% experience loyalty from Conscious Consumers despite not leading on sustainability messaging—the furniture arrives on time, looks like the photos, and the return process works.
The Emerging Brand Playbook: When Values Must Lead
If legacy brands win on experience, how do emerging conscious brands compete? Our data reveals a clear pattern: when you don't have decades of experience to lean on, values and transparent communication become your competitive differentiator.
Practices/Awareness as primary selection driver:
Ecobee: 32% of Conscious Consumers cite practices/awareness (vs. only 15% citing experience)
Anderson Windows & Doors: 28% cite practices/awareness
IKEA: 23% cite practices/awareness (showing values work even with scale)
These brands can't compete on experience familiarity yet—but they can compete on values clarity. When asked which brand best aligns with consumers who prioritize supporting local and small businesses, Anderson Windows & Doors captured 28% of Aspirational Conscious Consumers—nearly double Whirlpool's 16% despite Whirlpool's massive market presence.
Ecobee shows how values communication works when the experience base is still building. Among Conscious Consumers who selected Ecobee, only 15% cited brand experience—but 32% cited the company's practices and awareness efforts. The brand is winning customers by being radically clear about what it stands for, even while those customers are still forming their experience-based opinions.
Cali Floors represents another emerging brand approach: leading with product quality and materials as a trust signal. Among Conscious Consumers who chose Cali Floors, 50% cited materials as their primary reason—far above any other brand. For Aspirational Conscious Consumers, that number was 46%. When you can't lean on brand familiarity, leading with tangible product differentiation creates its own form of proof.
The emerging brand advantage is this: you can lead with values and practices while building the experience base that will eventually become your primary driver. Anderson, Ecobee, and Cali Floors are banking values-driven trust now that will compound into experience-driven loyalty later.
→ Click here to create your very own brand playbook!
The Generational Cliff
Our data reveals a dramatic generational divide that most brands are missing:
Core Conscious Consumer rates by generation:
Gen Z: 23%
Millennials: 21%
Gen X: 10%
Baby Boomers: 3%
Gen Z and Millennials are 7x more likely to be Core Conscious Consumers than Baby Boomers. But here's the twist: across all age groups, 42% of Gen Z cite experience as their main brand driver—the highest of any generation.
The most conscious generation is also the most experience-focused. They're not choosing brands based on mission statements alone—they're expecting values and performance. This creates both opportunity and pressure for conscious brands: younger consumers care deeply about your values, but they won't give you a pass on execution.
The Gender Action Gap
Women show higher overall conscious consumer identification than men (75% vs. 69%), suggesting stronger interest in ethical, social, and environmental values. But men are more likely to identify as Core Conscious Consumers (17% vs. 12%), indicating they more frequently act on these values.
This creates a strategic opportunity: brands can help women bridge their intent-to-action gap by removing the barriers we identified (cost, information, availability, performance) while reinforcing men's existing behaviors through consistent delivery and proof points.
What This Means for Your Brand Strategy
Our research reveals that conscious consumers aren't choosing between values and experience—they're demanding both. But the path to winning them depends entirely on where your brand sits on the trust curve.
If you're a legacy brand with established market presence:
Your advantage is decades of banked experience. Consumers already know you deliver. Now layer in values clarity. GE demonstrates this path: among Unlikely Conscious Consumers (the skeptics), 42% who prioritize certifications and transparency selected GE—the highest of any brand. GE isn't repositioning as a purpose-driven startup. It's proving values through actions, certifications, and transparent communication while leaning on its reliability reputation.
Your playbook: Lead with proof points, highlight reliability, and communicate values through actions, not slogans. Let your track record do the heavy lifting while you add values credibility through certifications, transparent reporting, and operational changes consumers can verify.
If you're an emerging conscious brand:
Your advantage is values clarity and authentic story. You can't compete on experience familiarity yet—but you can compete on making your values unmistakable. Anderson Windows & Doors captures 28% of local/small business-focused Aspirational Consumers by leaning into that positioning. Ecobee wins 32% on practices and awareness by being radically transparent about what they stand for.
Your playbook: Make your values and practices visible in every customer interaction. Invest in education and discovery experiences. Remove friction from the conscious choice. Show clear performance benefits alongside values. And remember: you're building the experience base now that will become your primary competitive advantage later. Every consistent delivery is a deposit in your future trust account.
For all brands, five barriers must be solved:
Higher Costs (50% overall barrier) – Find ways to demonstrate value that justifies premium pricing, or find efficiencies that close the price gap
Lack of Information (36% overall barrier) – Make your proof points accessible, clear, and verifiable
Limited Availability (25% overall barrier) – Expand distribution strategically, or make online purchasing seamless
Inferior Taste/Performance (58% for health/wellness buyers) – This is non-negotiable. Product quality must match or exceed conventional alternatives
Greenwashing/Misinformation (34% for environmental buyers) – Build trust through third-party certifications and transparent, verifiable claims
Only 6% of consumers say none of these barriers apply, meaning 94% of conscious consumers face real friction in making values-aligned purchases. The brands that remove these barriers will capture market share not just from other conscious brands, but from legacy players competing only on familiarity.
The Bottom Line for Conscious Brands
The conscious consumer market is growing, but it's not growing the way most brands think. Our research reveals three critical insights:
Experience drives loyalty more than values alignment—even among Core Conscious Consumers who cite it as their primary driver (46%)
Performance barriers remain the biggest obstacle—58% of the largest segment cite inferior taste/performance as their main barrier
The largest segment (37% Aspirational) needs accessibility, not complexity—they want to make conscious choices but need brands to make it easier
Conscious brands that understand these insights will capture market share not just from other conscious brands, but from legacy brands that compete only on performance. The ones that continue marketing only to values while ignoring experience will find themselves squeezed between values-focused competitors and experience-optimized legacy players.
IKEA proves the model works at scale: 24% of U.S. residents say it best aligns with their values, while 40% of Conscious Consumers cite experience as their reason for choosing it. The brands winning this market aren't choosing between values and experience—they're delivering both.
Values matter. But performance and experience are what create customers for life.
Want to understand exactly what drives your conscious customers? Download our research-backed guide: "7 Proof Points Every Brand Needs to Win the Conscious Consumer" and discover the specific evidence conscious consumers need to choose your brand.
Click here to get Your Free Guide
This analysis is based on Guru's proprietary research study of 2,200+ consumers across the conscious spectrum, conducted in partnership with Portland Marketing Analytics. For more insights into conscious consumer behavior, visit weareguru.com or connect with our research team at hello@weareguru.com.
